Submitted by Midnight on Wed, 10/15/2008 - 7:19am.

I recently purchased a D-Link Gamerlounge DGL-4500 Xtreme N Gaming Router. In this thread I will post my thoughts about it in a somewhat realtime manner as I begin using it. It will eventually be a full review, but I'm going to write it as a stream of consciousness rather than a complete review. Read on for my experience thus far.
I just purchased it two days ago and installed it yesterday, but I still don't have all the features configured or any experience with it during online gaming.
First, I purchased it because I run two Xbox 360s in my house, sometimes gaming at the same time, and my current router (~4 year old Belkin Wireless G router) can't support open NAT on both. This creates interesting problems when trying to host and organize online games. Another small problem that it promises to fix is increase in ping times to your online gaming host while another network computer is uploading or downloading large amounts of data.
It supposedly fixes this by prioritizing network traffic to allow gaming data through first. I don't know how it works, but it sounds great. Perhaps I'll learn in the coming days. It also has 802.11n (draft), but I currently don't have any devices that support N, so that's just some incentive for the future. It also has an LED display.
The router is a little expensive at $170 delivered from Amazon. I wasn't excited about paying this much, but my previous router lasted many years. Not only was it getting old, but it lacked several features that I want and would use regularly. I get a lot of utility from my home networking equipment through online gaming, LANs, and my home theater PC, so it was worth the $ to me to buy a quality router with lots of features, because I tend to use those features.
Last night I installed the router, upgraded the firmware, set up my wireless network, and set up MAC address filtering. My wireless security is to not broadcast my SSID plus only allow approved MAC addresses. Yes, it's possible to find out my SSID and spoof a MAC address, but it's not very probable--especially in light of all the open and WEP encrypted networks around me.
Upgrading the firmware was easy. Some reviews complained about it. I think the complaints are unfounded. Setting up MAC address filtering was essentially easy, but I did stumble on one nuance: make sure the first MAC address you add to the approved list is the MAC of the device you're using, or you essentially lock yourself out of the router and must do a hard reset to default settings.
Yeah. It happened twice.
After that things went smoothly. Both Xbox 360s have open NAT and all my devices are online. It integrated seamlessly with my existing 16-port switch that services all my home network drops. However, it appears that I must reconfigure my Vista Media Center machine (HTPC) with my Media Center Extenders (Xbox 360s). Changing the router seems to have destroyed the connection, but that should be simple enough to fix. I plan to drag the HTPC out of the closet and tackle that tonight (hopefully before the debate).